Publisher and bookseller Otto Penzler has harbored a lifelong admiration for Patricia Highsmith’s literary contributions, yet his inaugural encounter with the author was anything but successful. In 1984, the then 63-year-old novelist agreed to a reading at The Mysterious Bookshop, Penzler’s establishment on West 56th Street in New York. Having spent two decades residing in England, France, and Switzerland, Highsmith was a rare figure in public life, prompting high expectations for the event. Instead, the turnout was meager, and Penzler describes the interaction as remarkably cold, noting her disdain for small talk and a blunt dismissal regarding France. Then 63, had lived in Europe for 20 years – in England, then France, then Switzerland – and seldom made public appearances, so he had high hopes, the American author of the Ripley novels. According to we had maybe four people,” Penzler, From his book-lined office under the shop. People got their book signed and left within five minutes. So what does one do, i had a two-hour event scheduled. He signed a six-book deal with Highsmith, creating a new imprint in the process. “Pat didn’t want to be identified as a mystery writer, so I started Penzler Books, not yet knowing this. He knew Highsmith’s first editor, Joan Kahn. “When I told her I’d bought Pat, she said: ‘God, what’s wrong with you. Which made life tricky for her champions, she hated publicity. My wife said, ‘Oh, what a sweet thing. According to the interviews were brief and sometimes never published. “The one time Pat, Something positive was when I asked if she’d like to stop for a drink. Highsmith’s Swiss editor, Anna von Planta, recalled a similar first encounter in 1984: “Pat greeted me coolly, disregarding my extended hand. Penzler remembers that on one book tour, “my wife and I took her to our most beloved Italian restaurant. Whose job it was to take Pat to all the interviews, came with two long-stemmed roses, a young publicist.
Now 84, Penzler reflects on his experience after returning from a crime fiction convention. He characterizes Highsmith as a difficult personality who struggled to maintain long-term professional relationships in the United States. Following her 1950 debutStrangers on a Trainand the success ofThe Talented Mr Ripleyher American prospects waned by the mid-1960s. Publishers found her writing style too subtle and her characters overly unlikable, leaving her without a domestic home for her work by 1984. Penzler admits that while he attempted to build a professional bridge, her unpleasant nature made her a challenging figure to support. Now 84, with a tidy white beard and a warm, amused manner, he is just back from a crime fiction convention and still very much in the game. Highsmith, who was born in Fort Worth, Texas, in 1921, had a hit with her 1950 debut, Strangers on a Train, boosted by Alfred Hitchcock’s film. Lesbian road trip The Price of Salt (later republished as Carol), sold a million copies under the pseudonym Claire Morgan, and The Talented Mr Ripley (1955) was a critical success, a perfect second novel. “She never found a home because she was so unpleasant,” Penzler says. “I don’t think anybody said, ‘Oh look, we’re losing money but I love her so much, let’s keep her. Unrequited love and a poisonous mother, happiness largely eluded her, tortured by her sexuality. Pat threw hers on the floor without making eye contact.
Highsmith’s complex legacy is currently being explored in Anton Corbijn’s new film A Talent for Murder.
Based on Joanna Murray-Smith’s 2014 play Switzerland the production stars Helen Mirren as a dying Highsmith. Mirren is noted for her precise portrayal of the author’s physicality, from her distinct posture to her use of dark contact lenses. The film, set in 1995, depicts a solitary Highsmith who had previously ended her final relationship with translator Monique Buffet at the age of 66. While the film’s central narrative about a young editor seeking one final novel is fictional, it incorporates authentic details of her life, such as her companionship with pet snails and her penchant for cigarettes. By 1995, when the film is set, Highsmith had lived alone for years, ending her last relationship with the translator Monique Buffet, then 27, when she was 66. Of course, though lovingly built on real details, from the water glasses filled with cigarettes to her tank of pet snails and the Bond villain bunker she designed, it’s a fiction.
Critics often debate whether the image of the misanthrope has overshadowed Highsmith’s genuine talent.
While the recent Netflix adaptation of The Talented Mr Ripley has revitalized interest in her bibliography, some argue she deserves greater recognition for her technical prowess. With some authors, I can say, ‘Let me buy you dinner.
Literary agent Liz Calder, who oversaw Highsmith’s work at Bloomsbury until her death in 1995, recalls the author as a singular individual who often appeared more preoccupied with her pets—such as her parrot, Juju—than her human associates.
Her memorial service, held at the Chiesa di Tegna in Switzerland, marked the end of a career that had recently seen renewed interest following Anthony Minghella’s 1999 cinematic adaptation.
In contrast to the claims of her universal rudeness, her final American editor, Gary Fisketjon, maintained a positive relationship with her until his own recent passing in November 2026. Fisketjon described the author as deeply observant, particularly during dinners at the popular restaurant, the Odeon. He noted that Highsmith possessed an immense ability to capture human behavior in just a few pages, a skill he believed contributed to her ability to craft stories that resonate long after the final chapter. He published works such asFound in the Streetand the final Ripley installmentRipley Under Waternoting that their interactions were consistently civil.
The author’s posthumous reputation is further complicated by the discovery of 56 volumes of diaries, letters, and stories kept in her linen cupboard. These documents, managed by her long-term Swiss publisher Diogenes, revealed deep-seated prejudices, including antisemitism and racism. Despite these revelations, those who worked with her continue to emphasize the quality of her craft, specifically her dark, precise, and uniquely compelling narrative voice. Her Swiss editor, Anna von Planta, remains a primary guardian of this legacy, managing the estate that continues to challenge and fascinate contemporary readers.

















